Producent: Bachelet-Ramonet×Wis filters
(Copied from informal notes)
Marc Colin Puligny-Montrachet Premier Cru Les Garennes 1992 versus
Bachelet-Ramonet Bienvenue-Batard-Montrachet Grand Cru 1992: Oh man. The Bachelet-Ramonet was the shame of the night. It lost hands down against the Marc Colin. It was probably over the hill, but then it never could have been much (I never tasted it before because I got it as a gift), because fine 1992 Grand Cru Montrachets are showing pretty well at this age (had a beautiful Guy Amiot Montrachet 1992 recently which I rated 98...). I did not find notes for this wine, but RP does not rate other vintages very high either. No surprise. The Marc Colin was a fine example of a mature white Burgundy, with nice nutty character, butter, good acidity to carry it all.
PJ 14,0 • Edwin 15,2 • Walter 14,8 • Guy 12,6 • Dirk 10,0 • Frank 13,0 • Alain 12,5 • Hans 15,4 - Groepscore: 13,4/20 (84/100)
Marc Colin Puligny-Montrachet Premier Cru Les Garennes 1992 versus
Bachelet-Ramonet Bienvenue-Batard-Montrachet Grand Cru 1992: Oh man. The Bachelet-Ramonet was the shame of the night. It lost hands down against the Marc Colin. It was probably over the hill, but then it never could have been much (I never tasted it before because I got it as a gift), because fine 1992 Grand Cru Montrachets are showing pretty well at this age (had a beautiful Guy Amiot Montrachet 1992 recently which I rated 98...). I did not find notes for this wine, but RP does not rate other vintages very high either. No surprise. The Marc Colin was a fine example of a mature white Burgundy, with nice nutty character, butter, good acidity to carry it all.
PJ 14,0 • Edwin 15,2 • Walter 14,8 • Guy 12,6 • Dirk 10,0 • Frank 13,0 • Alain 12,5 • Hans 15,4 - Groepscore: 13,4/20 (84/100)
Beginnende pommadé, dus eerste premox toetsen, bedekt het witte fruit eronder. De mond heeft nog meer te lijden onder de premox dan de vorige, met volatiele toetsen, bitter, niet geïntegreerd. Kookwijn.
Alain 12,5 • Hans 11,0 • Walter 12,0 • Frank 13,5 • Jean-Paul 12,0 • Dirk 12,0 • Frans 12,5 • Ive • Michiel 12,8 - Groepscore: 12,3/20 (81/100)
Alain 12,5 • Hans 11,0 • Walter 12,0 • Frank 13,5 • Jean-Paul 12,0 • Dirk 12,0 • Frans 12,5 • Ive • Michiel 12,8 - Groepscore: 12,3/20 (81/100)
- Eerste
- «
- 1
- »
- Laatste